Madelaine Petsch

Maya

Richard Brake

Sheriff Rotter

Ema Horvath

Shelly / Pinup

Gabriel Basso

Gregory / Scarecrow

Pedro Leandro

Deputy Walters

Rachel Shenton

Debbie

George Young

Howard

Kyle Breitkopf

Teenage Gregory / Scarecrow

Finn Cofell

Teenage Pinup

Stevee Davies

Dougie

Hannah Galway

Claire

Sara Freedland

Annie

Dani Klupsch

Carrie

Ella Bruccoleri

Jasmine

Krystal Ellsworth

Dollface