Roddy McDowall

Bullwhip Griffin

Suzanne Pleshette

Arabella Flagg

Karl Malden

Judge Higgins

Harry Guardino

Sam Trimble

Richard Haydn

Quentin Bartlett

Hermione Baddeley

Miss Irene Chesney

Bryan Russell

Jack Flagg

Liam Redmond

Capt. Swain

Cecil Kellaway

Mr. Pemberton

Joby Baker

Bandido Leader

Mike Mazurki

Mountain Ox

Alan Carney

Joe Turner

Chuck Roberson

Cook (uncredited)

Parley Baer

Chief Executioner

Arthur Hunnicutt

Referee