Buster Keaton

James 'Jimmie' Shannon

T. Roy Barnes

Billy Meekin, His Partner

Snitz Edwards

His Lawyer

Ruth Dwyer

Mary Jones, His Girl

Frances Raymond

Mrs. Jones, Her Mother

Erwin Connelly

The Clergyman

Jules Cowles

The Hired Hand

Eugenia Gilbert

First Chance: Girl Who Laughs at Jimmie at the Club

Doris Deane

Second Chance: Girl Who Laughs at Jimmie at the Golf Course

Judy King

Third Chance: Girl Who Shreds 'Will You Marry Me' Note

Hazel Deane

Fourth Chance: Girl Who Refuses on a False Assumption

Bartine Burkett

Fifth Chance: Girl Proposed to Going Up the Staircase

Connie Evans

Sixth Chance: Girl Proposed to Going Down the Staircase

Pauline Toller

Seventh Chance: Girl Proposed to in the Phone Booth

Jean Arthur

Miss Smith the Country Club Receptionist (uncredited)