Douglas Fairbanks

The Duke of Arnoldo / The Black Pirate

Billie Dove

Princess Isobel

Anders Randolf

Pirate Captain

Donald Crisp

MacTavish

Tempe Pigott

Duenna (as Tempe Pigett)

Sam De Grasse

Pirate Lieutenant

Charles Stevens

Powder Man

John Wallace

Peg-Leg Pirate

Fred Becker

Pirate

Charles Belcher

Chief Passenger - Nobleman

E.J. Ratcliffe

The Governor

Nino Cochise

Pirate (uncredited)

Barry Norton

Youth (uncredited)

Mary Pickford

Princess Isobel in Final Embrace - Cameo Appearance (uncredited)